Send me fixes if you see something wrong on my tabs, I'll consider them and update if necessary, as long as I'm alive
I'm not a drummer so my drum tracks can be improved, and I'd be happy to fix them !
How do I rate tabs ? (I only check & rate Guitar Pro tabs)
5-star rating : you need to have tabbed at least all essential instruments : guitars, bass and drums, the other instruments are optional, except when they are the main ones.
You MUST apply "palm mutes" if required (I'm tired of seeing tabs missing them).
All tracks must be quite accurate, a few mistakes here and there is not important as long as it remains close to the original.
4-star rating : Like the 5-star but SOME instruments (not too many) are missing (bass, drums or background instruments), or there are too many mistakes to get a 5-star (wrong notes, bar missing...).
Your tab may be good, but the same one with all instruments is better.
3-star rating : only part of the song is tabbed (too many instruments missing or incomplete tab) but what is tabbed is good.
You may get this rating if some main riffs / parts are really wrong but the other parts is OK.
You may also get this rating if your tab is significantly less good than already existing tabs (you should only upload new tabs if it improves the existing ones).
It may also mean that your GP tab doesn't play properly in Guitar Pro. I try to take into account the version differencies and GP bugs but you must care about how it sounds in GP (version 5 and/or 6).
2-star rating : sorry, too many mistakes, notes wrong, too many instruments/parts missing
1-star rating : if I'm asking myself "what the hell is that ?" when I see or hear your tab.
I usually comment if I give a tab a 3-star rating or less, I may change my rating if I see that the issues are fixed, and you notify me of the change.